“Why Nursing Home Reform Fails,” by James A. Lomastro, Health Affairs

Quote:

“There is a structural reason why nursing home reform consistently disappoints, and it has almost nothing to do with which Medicare plan a resident is enrolled in. Across four decades of health care administration and advocacy work, I have watched versions of the same pattern repeat: A new payment model arrives with genuine promise, is embedded in an industry organized around the separation of revenue from care, and produces incremental gains at the margins while leaving the underlying architecture untouched. We are watching it happen again, this time with Institutional Special Needs Plans (I-SNPs).”

LTC Comment, Stephen A. Moses, President, Center for Long-Term Care Reform:

This is a fascinating article and it makes a crucial point. The gap between nursing home payers (Medicare, Medicaid, etc.) and caregivers often results in less than optimal care. But the problem has its root in the managed care system that permeates LTC today not in nursing homes’ corporate structure. Whether Medicare Advantage or Medicaid Managed LTC is paying, the funds go through a Managed Care Organization (MCO), not directly to the caregiver. Government’s complicated third-party financing of most LTC is the source of the problem. In a free market, where most LTC is purchased by individuals privately with private insurance reserved for catastrophically expensive cases and Medicaid is limited to genuinely needy people, everyone gets what they want. Billions of individual purchases of care produce price data that inform businesses and entrepreneurs what consumers want and how they should invest their capital. The current government-based LTC system produces no price data and results in the kind of complicated, counterproductive outcomes this article describes.